|
The
Glycerol Controversy
Ellen Coleman, RD, MA, MPH © 2004
In 1997, the United States Olympic Committee announced the addition
of glycerol to the banned substances list. The USOC ban is based
on glycerol being classified as a diuretic, since in high doses
(1 to 2 g per kg) it can be used to "make weight."
Glycerol hyperhydration may also confer an unfair athletic advantage
by reducing heat stress. Several studies have suggested that glycerol
hyperhydration increases plasma volume and sweat rate, thereby
reducing body temperature and improving performance during prolonged
exercise in warm weather. Glycerol may provide more substrate
energy (glycerol is broken down to dehydroxyacetone).
In one of the first studies, T. Lyons (a graduate student) and
colleagues at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque found
that glycerol hyperhydration was more effective than water hyperhydration
in reducing the thermal stress of moderate exercise in the heat
(see Lyons, 1990). The subjects consumed either 1 g of glycerol
per kg along with 21.4 ml of water per kg (glycerol trial) or
21.4 ml of water per kg (water trial). Two and one half hours
after fluid ingestion, the subjects exercised on a treadmill at
60% of VO2Max in dry heat (42 degrees C) for two hours. The urine
volume prior to exercise was decreased in the glycerol trial compared
to the water trial, indicating a glycerol-induced hyperhydration.
During exercise in the heat, the glycerol trial caused an elevated
sweat rate and lowered body temperature compared to the water
trial.
In a later double-blind, crossover study, Paul Montner, M.D.
and colleagues at the Veterans Administration Hospital in Albuquerque,
New Mexico evaluated the effect of glycerol hyperhydration and
carbohydrate oral replacement solution (ORS) on thermoregulation
and endurance performance (see Montner, 1996). In the first part
of the study, the subjects consumed either 1.2 g of glycerol per
kg along with 26 ml of water per kg (glycerol trial) or 26 ml
of water per kg (water trial) before exercise. The subjects cycled
on two separate days at 65% of VO2Max in a neutral laboratory
environment. Glycerol hyperhydration was associated with a significantly
longer endurance time (93.8 minutes) and lower heart rate (2.8
beats/minute) compared to water hyperhydration (77.4 minutes).
Next: "Part
2"
|