Tri Club
Coaches Forum
In March '06 I was invited to attend
a coaches forum for a local tri club, conducting in the format of a
round table discussion with a group of local tri coaches fielding
questions from the membership. I was called out of town on a family
emergency but was provided with the questions asked. Here are my
responses on a number of topics:
Question:
Would it be beneficial to spend maybe one
or two weeks and just focus on one discipline? Like cycling
5 days in one week with lots and lots of miles, or so? Or getting
my running miles up to 60-90 miles in one week and then backing
off?
A: I think focused weeks are a valuable training
tool. I use them in two places on the season:
- Off-Season, or perhaps pre-season. Whatever you
want to call a block of time during which you're not training
for a specific week. During these periods over the
past couple years I've had great success training athletes
for a half marathon PR and building 40k time trial cycling fitness.
During this period we typically focus on run frequency and
cycling intensity while decreasing, or eliminating all together,
our focus on training volume.
- More to your question, the structure above is
one that I've used extensively with Ironman athletes. In
the later points of the season, the requirement to do a 2-2.5hr
long run and 4-5.5 or 6hr long ride each week begins to conflict
with each other. At this point, about 7-11 weeks out from
their goal race, we shift to a Bike Week, Run Week format.
During the Bike Week, we turn down the long run and schedule
2 x long rides. During the Run Week, we turn down the long
bike a bit, and schedule two long runs, each shorter than
the “normal” long run.
The specific structure you outline above
would be very doable on the bike. I would call this Epic Training
and can be a good training stimulus and just a cool thing to
do. I've experimented with extremely high cycling volume and
have gotten a good fitness pop. For the run, I would
recommend you focus on a period of high run frequency,
not volume. This past season my northern athletes experimented
with “30 runs in 30 days,” with two dudes going
head to head for 80-90 straight run days. This is not for everyone,
obviously, but the focus on run frequency is probably a bit
less risky then run volume. Under this regimen, I would count
anything longer than 20' as a run.
Question:
I have a question on nutrition. I'm trying to
drop another 10-15lbs before I do IMCDA June 25th. What is
the best way to do so, during my training without losing fitness?
It's been hard for me lately. I took of 7 weeks during Christmas
because of an Injury, and it's taking a while to shed those
lbs. But I know I can stand to lose the lbs but I don't want
to bonk during or after training. Thanks Read these links:
- Training Nutrition Summary
- Paleo Diet, Modified for Endurance Athletes
Question:
I see a lot of different running postures and
techniques. Is there one “right” form?
A: I've attended a Pose clinic and have used
that teaching method, with a few modifications, for a
couple years. I now subscribe to the ideas and concepts in
Evolution Running. I have no direct experience with Chi Running.
Question:
What are some good drills to work on proper running
form?
A: I highly recommend you purchase a copy of
Evolution Running. The author, Ken Meirke, is a fellow Joe
Friel Ultrafit Associate. Ken has honed his methods while
analyzing the running form, gait, and oxygen intake of literally
thousands of athletes. In other words, he has been able to
quantitatively identify increases in speed at stable or decreased
oxygen intake levels due to specific changes in running
form and technique. He's the real deal.
Question:
Why is running such a common way to injure yourself
and what do you (personally) do for injury prevention?
A: My keys:
- Measure volume in time, not miles.
- Focus on creating a schedule of consistent, high
frequency running that you can execute, without injury, week
after week. In my experience, becoming a faster triathlon
runner is more often about simply running, week after week,
month after month, year after year, without getting hurt.
Get faster by outlasting your competition, who is more likely
to jump to soon into the sexy get-faster run training.
- Never, ever, ever compromise on running shoes.
- Do your harder runs up hills, easier on your
body.
- Be careful running downhill. This can be a valuable
training tool for building strong, hard, fatigue resistant
legs but is also risky.
- Walking cool down, stretch, hydrate, ibuprofen,
glucosamine, ice and elevation and a nap…under ideal
circumstances
Question:
Is a power meter good for everyone?
A: I've been training, racing and coaching with
a powermeter since 2002. I credit much of my personal cycling
success to the training and execution detail that this tool
has allowed me to achieve. However, the most successful power-training
athletes I've coached have taken an active interest in partnering
with me to learn how to train and race with power. If you are
not committed to reading a few books, training articles, learning
how to analyze your files with software, download your files,
perhaps troubleshoot computer issues, etc, then perhaps a simple
heart rate monitor would be a better expense.
I will say this: in the hierarchy of sexy training
and racing tools, a powermeter is right at the top and I won't
let my athletes purchase race wheels unless they already have
a powermeter.
Question:
If one leg is much weaker and always aches (and
you do weights), what can I do? I have a short leg. My longer
leg is the weaker leg. When I wear fins, that leg really
hurts for some reason and my foot cramps too. It is getting
worse with age (all due to scoliosis). I have lifts in both
my biking and running shoes on the outside.
A: I'm not comfortable giving training advice
to such a special case without having a qualified professional
give me an assessment first.
Question:
How long after a workout (mine are typically
between 30 minutes and 2 hours depending on the day) should
I try to eat and what kinds of things should I try to eat (both
what types of calories and what particular foods are good places
to find the right balance)
A: For training sessions of 60+ minutes, I recommend
a liquid recovery meal, within 1hr of completing the session,
with a 4-1 ratio of carbs to protein, ie, a simple smoothie
with some protein powder. Chocolate milk is a good option as
well and cheaper than XYZ Recovery Powder. I try to get in
about 500-800 calories and then eat normally the rest of the
day. I monitor how my legs are recovering through the day.
If they feel abnormally fatigued, I'll eat “good carbs” of
fruit and vegetables.
Again, more complete information in these two
articles:
- Training Nutrition Summary
- Paleo Diet, Modified for Endurance Athletes
Question:
I was a college aquatic athlete so my pool workouts
are ok, and I have access to a group who do track workouts
for running. My questions is, aside from doing longer and harder
rides, what can I do on the bike to get that kind of workout.
I have done some 30 seconds easy / 30 seconds hard style pieces
but I don't really know what to do or if it even helps on the
bike.
A: Perform a 40' time trial on the bike, going
has hard as you can go, keeping an even pace for the entire
40'. At 40 minutes you should have no gas in the tank, in other
words. A flat course, in the aerobars, at “normal” cadence
is preferred. Take your average heart rate for this test. This
is a “good enough” estimate of your lactate threshold
heart rate. Your speed at lactate threshold is an excellent
indicator of your speed at all intensities. In other words,
by training to lift your speed at LT, say, from 20mph to 22mph,
it also becomes easier to ride 20mph vs 18mph.
I am a BIG believer in interval training performed
at or near your lactate threshold heart rate. I run my athletes
through a progression of intervals: 3-4 x 8-20', totaling 30-50'
of work interval time. For example, 3 x 8', 3 x 10', 2 x 15',
etc. Going over 50' of total work interval time in a session
is usually too costly unless the athlete has exceptional recovery
resources.
The idea with these is to expose yourself to
this intensity level for relatively long periods of time. Sitting
at or just under LT enables you do these longer 8-20' intervals
vs the 30” intervals you were doing. It's simple a better
training stimulus.
Question:
How do I know if I need a coach?
A: I believe that the more time constrained you
are, or the higher your goals, the more you need a coach. If
you are time constrained, you likely don't have a lot of time
available to read, learn, or experiment on your own to find
what does and does not work. Probably 2/3 of my athletes are
self-employed consultant types who, being experts in their fields,
realize the value of hiring someone to do all the hard work
for them so they can focus on what they do best, rather than
planning their own training.
Likewise, a good coach has seen every possible
permutation and iteration of every fitness limiter, training
time challenge, and special situation you can imagine. They
have a very large bag of tricks to help you get in the training
you need to get done, help you prioritize when the real world
comes knocking, and have done enough experimenting with their
own training, and across dozens of athletes, to learn what
does and does not work.
So in the end, it's usually a matter of learning
by making the time investment and training mistakes or yourself,
or hiring someone who has been there, done that across scores
of athletes and in their own training.
Question:
I have a job & family, how do I prioritize
my limited training time?
A: Wow, that's a big one •
- Schedule a consult with me so I can tell you
exactly what you need to do and when in the season, given
your current fitness, goals and time constraints.
- Honestly communicate this structure and requirements
to your family. In January, my athletes are able to ask for
the green light for training weekends in July. No surprises
when the training hammer falls.
- Focus on ROI for each training minute spent.
If you can achieve the same fitness and speed returns
in a 2hr bike as you can with a 3hr bike, why waste an hour?
Is noodling around the bike paths for 4hrs in February the
best investment of your time, vs a short and sweet hammer
session (see LT question) that is over with and done in 2hrs?
- Train on your time, not your families: basically,
if you're a busy family person, the sun is up and you're
not training then you're either sleeping (which is fine)
or you've shifted your training to your family's time.
- If possible, work your training into your commute.
I know many athletes who drive part way to work, run into
and out of the office from their cars. Or ride to/from
work. Or combine workouts: bike + run = only one shower and
costume change. Get creative.
Question:
What is the minimum training time needed to be
ready for a sprint, Olympic, or half Ironman?
A: The minimum time required is the time you
have available. By this, I mean your training plan fits
within YOUR lifestyle and time budget, not the other way around.
Within this thought, don't focus on overall weekly volume but
rather the volume of your long training events. For sprint
and Olympic I'd say you should work yourself up to a 1hr long
run and 2hr long bike. Then within this requirement schedule
an additional 2-3 runs, 2 bikes, and 2-3 runs. The length of
these additional, non-long sessions is ENTIRELY a function
of your time available to train. In other words, your Wed morning
run is 40' because you have 40' to run, not because a training
schedule says it needs to be 40'. This logistics-dictated scheduling
is what I use with every athlete, Sprint to Ironman.
For Half Ironman, these long event volumes scale
up to a 1.5 2hr long run and 3hr long ride. That said, the
two most valuable weekly training sessions you can build to,
regardless of race distance, are regular 1.5hr long runs and
3hr long rides. In other words, from now until the end of time
you run 1.5hrs on Thursday morning and meet your friends for
a 3hr ride on Saturday. This discipline and consistency will
allow you to do anything in the sport.
Question:
What is the most common mistake that age group
athletes make?
A: Just one? :-) •
- Not creating a training plan that fits
their lifestyle and time constraints.
- Overvalue gear: trying to buy speed through the
latest aero carbon whizbang gadget.
- Undervalue knowledge: a $5k bike in the garage
and not one $20 book on the shelf. Or don't have a problem
spending $150 on two tubular tires but balk at a $100 training
plan.
- Not looking for the easy gains first. It's
not always about figuring out new and inventive ways
to bang your head against the wall. Look for the free and
easy stuff first: body composition, swimming/running
form, bike fit, etc.
- Underestimating the value of simple hard work
and consistency. When athletes ask me what I did to earn
my bike speed, I tell them I was on the Santa Fe Dam with
Jon Pedder at 5:30am every Tues and Thursday while they were
sleeping.
- Avoiding, or not seeking out, training events
and partners that challenge their perspective on what far
and fast are.
Question:
Starting from zero, how long does it take to
train for an Ironman?
A: Your goal long events for an Ironman are a
2.5hr long run, 5-6hr long ride, and a 4k swim, each completed
at least once before race day. Your current fitness will
determine how long it will take you to build to these distances.
If your current run is only 30', you're 50 pounds overweight
with a history of running injuries, it will take you much longer
to build up to this 2.5hr long run than an athlete with a regular
1.5hr long run and 12% body fat. That said, from absolute zero
and no injuries, I'd say about 9 months on the low end, 12
on the safe end. Injuries and body composition will push those
numbers upwards. 18 months is possible for just about anyone
with the will to prepare.
Question:
Is training alone better than training with a
group?
A: No. Anything that reduces the mental cost
of training is more likely to help you retain your love of
the sport, leading to more consistent training year after year.
My most successful athletes have a menu of training partners
and groups to call upon for their key workouts or to simply
make the training fun…not training. Likewise, triathletes
often underestimate the training value of trying to hold a
faster athlete's wheel, or what they can learn by simply picking
that person's brain during a training ride or run. Some athletes
will tell you that since you will racing alone you should train
alone. There is some merit to that but I'll add a couple points.
First, you are not alone on race day. You're riding and running
with 2000 of your best friends and another 5000 volunteers.
Second, I'm pretty sure I can whack my head with a hammer.
I don't think I need to practice it more than a couple times.
In my experience, there is sooo much to think about and engage
your mind and attention on race day that I don't think you
need to practice isolation too much. However, the cost of training
solo all the time is to become stuck in a comfort zone that
a group session can lift you out of and to a new perspective
on far and fast.
Question:
How do I know if I'm training hard enough?
A: Don't think training hard, think training
effectively. Every training session should have a purpose that
address a specific limiter. If you can not identify the
purpose of a training session, or the clear benefit you
will receive from it, don't do it. Don't do a workout just
because it's on a spreadsheet. That said, tools like a heart
rate monitor, GPS or powermeter will help you assign numbers
to Easy, Steady, Upper-Steady, Moderate-Hard, and Hard so that
you can begin to quantify your training.
Question:
How can I overcome my fear of open water?
A: This is very common. Begin by swimming in
a safe lake with lifeguards and other swimmers near you, then
graduate to ocean swimming under similar conditions. Throughout,
count your strokes and focus on your form, as a means to take
your mind off of your fears.
Question:
Should I always train & race with a heart
rate monitor?
A: If you are new to the sport, a heart rate
monitor is a valuable tool. I encourage more experienced athletes
to add a powermeter and GPS to their training tools, so we
can put objective, quantifiable numbers behind their
training.
Question:
How do I set goals that are high but still obtainable?
A: First, find training partners who challenge
your perspective of what far and fast are. For example, 20mph
on the bike is only fast if the people around you tell you
it's fast. If all you know if 22mph, then 24mph is fast. Perspective.
Second, do a consult with me. I can help you assesses your
limiters, time available to train, and give you my honest assessment
of what is and is not possible.
Question:
I want to qualify for Kona, what do I need to
work on most?
A: Qualifying for men from 25 to 49 usually requires
a 9:50-10:30 Ironman. This is very consistent, for all age
groups. It's usually just a matter of how many of those freaks
show up, the number of slots available to them, and maybe getting
lucky in the roll down. So let's call it 10:00. The most common
method to get 10:00 is a 1:00 swim, 5:30 bike, 3:30 run, then
knock out a total of about 4-5 minutes for transitions. If
you are faster or slower than these splits, then you've bought/need
to pay for time someplace else. For example, a 55 swim and
5:20 bike has bought you a 3:45 run. However, a 1:15 swim needs
to be paid for with a 5:15 bike or 3:15 run. Those are the
numbers. Estimate where you are right now and you probably
have a good idea what it's going to take. Qualifying for a
Kona is worthy but lofty goal that can take several years of
chipping away at limiters and consolidating strengths. There
is no substitute for hard work and consistency.
Question:
What do you do with the pork
chop bone after eating the meat during a long training ride
or better yet race? Especially, with the new litter laws being
enforced by USAT?
A: I usually wrap mine up in the burrito wrapper
and stuff it someone else's singlet as I pass them on the bike.
Question:
Assuming one has developed a decent freestyle
stroke with reasonable body position and a good catch, how
important is the rate of stroke turn-over to an improved IM
swim split?
A: “Good” form will yield a stroke
count of 17-20 strokes per length. If you are an adult swimmer
and taking less than 16 or 17 strokes per length and are swimming
slower than about 40-45” per 50yd, you're trying too
hard, artificially gliding. They give medals for speed,
not stroke count, and “real” swimmers take about
16-18 strokes per length…they just go faster J. I've
noticed that swimmers gravitate to a faster stroke rate when
swimming open water, I think due to the increased forces acting
on their body: wind, waves, other swimmers, etc. They instinctively
realize they need to increase their stroke rate to keep moving
forward.
Question:
How much of a hindrance, to an improved IM-distance
swim split, is unilateral (one-sided) versus bilateral breathing?
A: bilateral breathing is a good tool to encourage
a good and balanced body rotation. If you are in process of
developing good swim habits, this is a good one to pick up.
Question:
If one is carrying excess weight (fat), but is
otherwise perfectly healthy, is there a point of diminishing
returns, from a performance perspective, when you're really
better off simply focusing on cutting caloric (food) intake
than increasing training duration (caloric expenditure)? Frequently,
after a workout, I come home famished and then, as a direct
consequence, driven to over-indulge -- seemly negating much
of the benefit of the workout. It is the quantity, not
the quality, of these calories that is of concern here.
A: Not sure I understand the question. It's usually
easier to create a calorie deficit by focusing on the
expenditure side rather than on the intake side, particularly
after long training events. For example, assume your basal
rate is 2500 calories and you ride for 4 hours, burning 3000
calories. You now need to eat about 5500 calories to maintain
your weight. You could eat 4500 calories and still create a
1000 calorie deficit. 4500 calories, if eaten as good,
healthy food, is a LOT of food. My keys for my own training
are:
- Eat enough right away to replenish muscle glycogen.
- Then eat normally the rest of the day, not using
the workout as an excuse to chow down.
- Focus on nutrient dense vs calorie dense. In
my fridge right now are tons of chicken breast, salmon filets,
a case of oranges, bananas, apples, grapes, strawberries,
heaps of vegetables, etc. Of course, I want the bagels in
the freezer but I save those for immediately after exercise.
Focus on making better food choices.
To create a similar 1000 calorie deficit
by focusing more on calories in vs calories in is probably
better termed starvation J. Again, my key is to just eat normally
after my long stuff, especially the bike.
Question:
With a middle-aged body, a long daily commute,
and a career/family/home to maintain, I find that it's
nearly impossible for me to strictly comply, for any length
of time, with ANY of the published IM training plans I've seen.
I can do the required weekly long swim/ride/run session, but
have difficultly doing the stuff in-between without either
physical melt-down, getting fired from work, or a divorce.
To maintain some semblance of a non-tri life, I find
it necessary to omit, or drastically shorten the duration of,
the mid-week workouts reflected in such training plans.
I believe this phenomenon, among “real world” age-groupers,
is much more common that the “expert” writers of
such training plans realize or care to admit. Please comment.
A: You describe yourself as an extremely busy
person whose time is very valuable. How much does your bike
cost? Your wetsuit? The airfare for your next race? Hotels?
Rental car? The generic training plan you're photocopying from
magazine?
Generic is just that: generic and off the shelf.
A large part of my business is writing quality, affordable
but generic training
plans for sale to athletes. These plans are not for everyone, but I and any
good Ironman coach could create a training
schedule that could help you achieve your Ironman goals given your personal
time constraints. So I would argue that the
divergence you describe isn't between coach and training plan but rather
you and the training plan.
Perhaps you should consider hiring or consulting
with a coach to write a personalized training schedule that
accounts for
your UNIQUE and personal time challenges.
That said, the “numbers,” based on my 4-5 years of Ironman coaching
experience are:
- Build to a 4k swim, 5-6hr long ride, 2-2.5hr
long run, each accomplished at least once (separately) before
race day.
- A total (minimums) of 3 swims, 3 rides, 3 runs
per week.
- Most athlete's IM volume settles around 6-9hrs
during recovery weeks, 12-15+ during other weeks.
- Special circumstances, strengths
and limiters will change those numbers. For example, a strong
swimmer may be able to not swim at all until 4 wks from their
race. A heavier athlete should spend more time on the bike, to
burn more calories in a lower risk environment.
All of my
training articles are also available at
Endurance Nation. As a
member of Endurance Nation you'll gain open access to over 25 training
plans, affordable group coaching solutions, 400+ articles, and join a
vibrant community of smart and supportive endurance athletes. Please
visit Endurance Nation to
learn more.
|